as seen in post #1108423

Character is female, but has a transparent ghost dick.

Opinions?

Random said:
as seen in post #1108423

Character is female, but has a transparent ghost dick.

Opinions?

I'd say yes, under logic that it's like a translucent penis. A type of penis is still a penis, unlike disembodied penis that is just a seperate entity.

Mind you, transparent penis is aliased to it...

That's actually a tough one.
Because it's hard to say if it counts as actual anatomy, or as a sex toy. Female with a magically conjured strap-on would still be tagged as female...

Still, I'd vote for herm. Simply because it's not an obvious sex toy, and from the search viewpoint that post is likely of more interest to users who search for herm.

Not sure about this one.. but.. I think the fact that it's a magic transparent ghost dick puts her into the dickgirl category, as far as TWYS goes at least, shouldn't it? That or maybe strap on? I mean it's pretty clear that she's anatomically 100% female with a magic (temporary) dick and no balls.. There's no physical transformation, just a non-physical modification.

Drkfce0 said:
Not sure about this one.. but.. I think the fact that it's a magic transparent ghost dick puts her into the dickgirl category, as far as TWYS goes at least, shouldn't it? That or maybe strap on? I mean it's pretty clear that she's anatomically 100% female with a magic (temporary) dick and no balls.. There's no physical transformation, just a non-physical modification.

Herm because they also have a visible pussy. Dickgirl is just penis.

There is such a thing as organic translucence, and there is no evidence suggesting it is anything but their penis (like, a dildo or disembodied penis), other than the magic that may be the reason it's translucent.

Kind of a gray area but I would say Yeah, She would be a Herm in the scenario or at the least be tagged both a Female and Herm since she would be able to fit the category of both of them. It's one of the special cases where the art could been seen ether way ya know? =)

Siral_Exan said:
Herm because they also have a visible pussy. Dickgirl is just penis.

There is such a thing as organic translucence, and there is no evidence suggesting it is anything but their penis (like, a dildo or disembodied penis), other than the magic that may be the reason it's translucent.

Guys got a point, For that to be a Dickgirl she would only have to have the D. Though since she has both a V and a D (With the D in a middle ground since it's transparent) She/They could be seen as ether a Female 'Or' a Herm. Hints to why I say both tags would work here ◠‿◠)

That's my reasoning anyway ~ ‿~)

Vote for herm. Magical or not, the penis appears to be an extension of the character, and there is a visible pussy. Doesn't fall under dickgirl because of two sets of visible genitalia.

If you ask me this would fall under some form of strapon. The problem you all have with pining this down as a herm is that the penis form is sitting on the slit of the pussy much like a strap on. The pussy is not exposed above or below the penis form as a separate genitalia.

Edit* Just for reference the source does state that it is a herm but what is visible is not visually a herm but a female that has some form of strapless magical sex toy sitting on their pussy

What's tripping me up is the fact that it doesn't seem to be connected in anyway...

If the dick were in fact attached, wouldn't the point at which the dick is attached also be transparent? In the case of the picture if the dick is actually attached then wouldn't we see the immediate internals right before the dick itself(flesh or muscle)? If not then I imagine the appendage is just a magically conjured extension as opposed to an actual body part.

Queen_Tyr'ahnee said:
What's tripping me up is the fact that it doesn't seem to be connected in anyway...

If the dick were in fact attached, wouldn't the point at which the dick is attached also be transparent? In the case of the picture if the dick is actually attached then wouldn't we see the immediate internals right before the dick itself(flesh or muscle)? If not then I imagine the appendage is just a magically conjured extension as opposed to an actual body part.

We can't see any means of it being attached, either, though. It's more likely it's a transparent dick, than a strap on.

I wouldn't say strap-on, but I think it's more a kind of sex toy made out of magic. It's not biological connected to her through flesh,muscles or nerves.

Yeah I think it is wrong to tag these as herm. Instead we should come up with a tag which fits for something that isn't transformation, but is instead is made of a conjured substance (magic, water, etc) excluding flesh or something that actually merges with the character.

improvised_dildo already kind of covers this, and I would say something to the effect of conjured_dildo or conjured_strapon might fit.

The below image is another example that just popped up so I figured I should bring this up again.

post #1137070

The philosophical discussions one has/finds on a hentai site. lol

The only thing i could see is maybe dickgirl and transformation.. She's not a herm, she's not a trans, and it can't really be called any type of strapon.

Other than that... maybe time for a new tag?

Drkfce0 said:
The philosophical discussions one has/finds on a hentai site. lol

The only thing i could see is maybe dickgirl and transformation.. She's not a herm, she's not a trans, and it can't really be called any type of strapon.

Other than that... maybe time for a new tag?

How could she be a dickgirl if she has a visible pussy?

Furrin_Gok said:
How could she be a dickgirl if she has a visible pussy?

Y'know, I seriously wanted to capitalize on that, but you did that for me. Thank you.

My evidence for it being a penis is it shows veins, it is in just enough of an anatomically correct position to ignore the scrotum-pussy clashing area with no clitoris to exaggerate the pussy, there is no base for the dildo, and that would be unwieldy if you held it in your hand (let's ignore magic since it supports both arguments), and the balls appear to be shifted with the leg, as if pushed to the side slightly.

magical_construct?

Siral_Exan said:
the balls appear to be shifted with the leg, as if pushed to the side slightly.

The thing HAS to be physicial touchable, a dick made out of air would miss the purpose I guess ;-)

In so far as we can clearly see the labia through the dick, I'm inclined to tag it as female.

I'm pretty sure there are pictures around already that involve "summoned" strap-ons (I wouldn't be super sure since I usually stick to gay stuff). Whatever tags're on those would be appropriate here?

Siral_Exan said:
Y'know, I seriously wanted to capitalize on that, but you did that for me. Thank you.

My evidence for it being a penis is it shows veins, it is in just enough of an anatomically correct position to ignore the scrotum-pussy clashing area with no clitoris to exaggerate the pussy, there is no base for the dildo, and that would be unwieldy if you held it in your hand (let's ignore magic since it supports both arguments), and the balls appear to be shifted with the leg, as if pushed to the side slightly.

One a dildo can have veins printed or embossed on its surface, two not all dildos are made with hard inflexible Plastic, different types of plastic have different consistencies and some of these can very well simulate the feel and physical dynamics of real balls...

Ruku said:
One a dildo can have veins printed or embossed on its surface, two not all dildos are made with hard inflexible Plastic, different types of plastic have different consistencies and some of these can very well simulate the feel and physical dynamics of real balls...

We do have a translucent_penis tag for a reason, though.

Furrin_Gok said:
We do have a translucent_penis tag for a reason, though.

generally that is used for disembodied penises thru.

we do also have translucent_dildo too also.

A translucent penis would be showing the urethra.

The only exception too all this are characters that are made of slime/goo covering another character.

Ruku said:
A translucent penis would be showing the urethra.

actually its quite rare for artists to include urethra on transparent dicks. you are putting too much faith on artists making everything 100% logically and according anatomy books

A temporary magic dick, even a full trsnsformation wouldn't change your gender, but as to a static image with TWYS it's not temporary, is it? Knowing its temporary would be TWYK.

DamienG said:
A temporary magic dick, even a full trsnsformation wouldn't change your gender, but as to a static image with TWYS it's not temporary, is it? Knowing its temporary would be TWYK.

The horn is glowing, which implies she has to use magic to keep it.

D4rk said:
The horn is glowing, which implies she has to use magic to keep it.

Not necessarily. Maybe the horn just glows. Saying it "only glows during active use" is TWYK.