Topic: Tagged animated, but really just a slideshow of static pictures

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

While I know this probably doesn't come up often enough to justify it's own tag (and already has a better alternative, namely pools), I thought it would be worthwhile to get some feedback regarding use of the tag.

To me "animated", in general, implies movement or life. A post like post #455869 (explicit) being labeled animated comes off as both somewhat misleading and not what I'm looking for in the first place. Furthermore it doesn't seem to follow the general purpose of e621's tagging system (find only what you are looking for).

I have seen this before, usually as .gif files of two or more derivative versions of a single picture (different facial features, one with visible orgasm, etc.), some even having been uploaded that way by the artist.

So far, I have thought of the following actions that could be taken (in no particular order):

  • Attempt to agree on a tag for the handful of posts it applies to (barely_animated? slideshow?)
  • Remove these posts and force them to be posted as pools instead (definitely no chance of conflicts happening here)
  • Do...well nothing (it is really of extremely little importance anyways)

I only offer this as a talking point, I am not suggesting that anything should be removed or anyone banned or that it is even a real problem.

Give me your thoughts.

Updated by Rainbow Dash

I'd suggest if they are such a bit annoyance, and all the child posts are in there, I think just having them in the pool is fine, but if the artist uploads it as such, I don't really see any other option.

Updated by anonymous

Should not be tagged as animated; slideshow is much more appropriate.

Updated by anonymous

These hairs, I'm splitting them.

20 minutes in and I can already tell that the line between slideshow and animated is blurry (and constantly moving) so I'll have to add slideshow for some and remove animated for some...but I'm not entirely sure if removing animated is worthwhile at this point.

Updated by anonymous

parasprite said:
These hairs, I'm splitting them.

20 minutes in and I can already tell that the line between slideshow and animated is blurry (and constantly moving) so I'll have to add slideshow for some and remove animated for some...but I'm not entirely sure if removing animated is worthwhile at this point.

If during the slideshow it shows images that have animation, such as gifs- they get both tags.

Updated by anonymous

123easy said:
If during the slideshow it shows images that have animation, such as gifs- they get both tags.

thank you

Updated by anonymous

  • 1