Topic: Disproportionate BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #12787 is pending approval.

create alias disproportionate (10) -> disproportionate_(disambiguation) (0)
change category disproportionate_(disambiguation) (0) -> invalid
create alias disproportionate_balls (1) -> hyper_balls (58753)
create alias disproportunate_breasts (5) -> hyper_breasts (62690)
create alias disproportionate_breasts (0) -> hyper_breasts (62690)
create alias disproportionately_shrunk (18) -> hyper_micro (26)
create alias disproportunate_butt (29) -> hyper_butt (28020)
create alias disproportionate_butt (0) -> hyper_butt (28020)

Reason: Some tags that I consider redundant as hyper-related tags describe the same concept. I decided to make a disambiguation tag for disproportionate as it seems to be used to describe both hyper and size difference/extreme size difference. I decided to leave out disproportionate_transformation for now as while it is applied somewhat inconsistently it does have a wiki page that gives it a clear definition that isn't really covered by any other tag.

The bulk update request #12788 is pending approval.

create alias disproportionately_detailed_mouth (6) -> detailed_mouth (668) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur
create alias disproportionately_detailed_anus (2) -> detailed_anus (2513) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur
create alias disproportionately_detailed_genitals (76) -> detailed_genitals (643) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur

Reason: More tags I considered redundant. Put these in a seperate BUR as they are not directly related to the previous one.

eightoflakes said:
create alias disproportionate (10) -> disproportionate_(disambiguation) (0)
change category disproportionate_(disambiguation) (0) -> invalid
create alias disproportionate_balls (1) -> hyper_balls (58823)
create alias disproportunate_breasts (5) -> hyper_breasts (62708)
create alias disproportionate_breasts (0) -> hyper_breasts (62708)
create alias disproportionately_shrunk (18) -> hyper_micro (26)
create alias disproportunate_butt (29) -> hyper_butt (28008)
create alias disproportionate_butt (0) -> hyper_butt (28008)

Reason: Some tags that I consider redundant as hyper-related tags describe the same concept. I decided to make a disambiguation tag for disproportionate as it seems to be used to describe both hyper and size difference/extreme size difference. I decided to leave out disproportionate_transformation for now as while it is applied somewhat inconsistently it does have a wiki page that gives it a clear definition that isn't really covered by any other tag.

I don't see how the term "disproportionate" could reliably translate to "hyper".

Considering we have the more established disproportionate_genitalia, the name could mean it can also be applied to characters who are of normal build but with disproportionately-sized genitals/body parts (e.g., a normal person with micropenis).

We should either alias all the disproportionate_* tags to disproportionate_(disambiguation) or make it subcategories for disproportionate_genitalia (or disproportionate_body_part).

eightoflakes said:
create alias disproportionately_detailed_mouth (6) -> detailed_mouth (668) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur
create alias disproportionately_detailed_anus (2) -> detailed_anus (2511) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur
create alias disproportionately_detailed_genitals (76) -> detailed_genitals (644) # has blocking transitive relationships, cannot be applied through bur

Reason: More tags I considered redundant. Put these in a seperate BUR as they are not directly related to the previous one.

They are far from being redundant, see selectively_detailed or topic #41960.

Gonna have to agree with Wolfgang here. Disproportionate can mean bigger or smaller than the rest of the body, not just overly big.

Original page: https://e621.net/forum_topics/60961?page=1