Topic: Should fellatio imply penis_in_mouth?

The bulk update request #12584 is pending approval.

create implication fellatio (182046) -> penis_in_mouth (40509)
create implication autofellatio (10360) -> penis_in_own_mouth (571)

Reason: If the penis doesn't enter the mouth, does it count as fellatio (can penis lick on its own count)?

If not, how much of the penis can be in mouth without it counting as penis in mouth?
post #2113583

We know that fellatio should not imply oral_penetration, but where on that scale does penis in mouth fall (in terms of amount of penis in mouth)? Is it fully on one side or the other, or is it in the middle, and if so, how do we distinguish the cases of: penis_in_mouth but not oral_penetration, fellatio but not penis_in_mouth?

The bulk update request #12585 is pending approval.

create implication oral_threading (638) -> penis_in_mouth (40509)

Reason: Tangential penis in mouth implication

The original BUR could run into a lot of mistags. Because fallatio can be performed so good deep that you can't even see the penis.
post #5976061

"Fellatio" means oral stimulation of the penis, so it definitely includes licking.

"Penis_in_mouth" is one of our very specific tags that I always forget to apply and personally don't find useful, but it has nearly 40K tags so clearly others are using it.

donkdewd said:
"Fellatio" means oral stimulation of the penis, so it definitely includes licking.

So where is the line between penis lick/tonguejob and fellatio

slyroon said:
The original BUR could run into a lot of mistags. Because fallatio can be performed so good deep that you can't even see the penis.
post #5976061

Well there's a reason penis in mouth doesn't imply penis. Or penis in vagina for that matter (topic #43321)

snpthecat said:
So where is the line between penis lick/tonguejob and fellatio

I don't think there is a line of division - I think "fellatio" should be an umbrella tag the various oral sex tags should implicate (to the extent they involve a dick and a mouth).

donkdewd said:
I don't think there is a line of division - I think "fellatio" should be an umbrella tag the various oral sex tags should implicate (to the extent they involve a dick and a mouth).

So irrumatio should imply fellatio?

snpthecat said:
So irrumatio should imply fellatio?

Never heard of that term in my life, so thanks for providing a link. If the gist is that it involves oral sex with a passive partner, probably not, since "fellatio" implies an active partner, imo.

donkdewd said:
Never heard of that term in my life, so thanks for providing a link. If the gist is that it involves oral sex with a passive partner, probably not, since "fellatio" implies an active partner, imo.

Hmm, would you consider urethral_tonguing (of a penis) as fellatio?

snpthecat said:
Hmm, would you consider urethral_tonguing (of a penis) as fellatio?

Since that act doesn't always involve a penis, the question is moot - an implication is not on the table anyway. I'm happy to leave the case-by-case judgment calls to the users who are into that content.

donkdewd said:
Since that act doesn't always involve a penis, the question is moot - an implication is not on the table anyway. I'm happy to leave the case-by-case judgment calls to the users who are into that content.

Not talking about it as an implication, just wanted to see what you would consider it to be, given that you intend to group all (active) oral sex acts that involve a penis and mouth into fellatio