Topic: [REJECTED] the yoshi species should imply yoshi's island primarily before mario bros. imo

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #12278 has been rejected.

create implication yoshi (7235) -> yoshi's_island (348)

Reason: Why doesn't the species' tag imply the one game that yoshi (or rather the members of its species) is/are the protagonist of?

Furthermore, if I may debate this: Should an upload that only includes the yoshi species tag, but not yoshi_(character), still be implying mario_bros?

EDIT: The bulk update request #12278 (forum #467680) has been rejected by @spe.

Updated by auto moderator

Yoshi first appeared in Super Mario World [1990], so if it implies any game it should be that. That being said, if a character or species appears in multiple games or installments in a franchise, it should imply the franchise rather than the game itself. Not all Yoshi interpretations are from Yoshi's Island [1995] and it would be inaccurate for yoshi to automatically impliy yoshi's_island.

Original page: https://e621.net/forum_topics/59672?page=1