Topic: Should mantle be an umbrella tag?

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

1Eyed-Rosd

Member

The bulk update request #9951 is pending approval.

create implication capelet (796) -> mantle (263)
create implication shawl (872) -> mantle (263)
create implication red_capelet (30) -> red_mantle (1)
create implication red_shawl (7) -> red_mantle (1)
create implication orange_capelet (2) -> orange_mantle (0)
create implication orange_shawl (3) -> orange_mantle (0)
create implication brown_capelet (4) -> brown_mantle (0)
create implication brown_shawl (1) -> brown_mantle (0)
create implication yellow_capelet (0) -> yellow_mantle (0)
create implication yellow_shawl (2) -> yellow_mantle (0)
create implication tan_caplet (0) -> tan_mantle (0)
create implication tan_shawl (1) -> tan_mantle (0)
create implication green_capelet (58) -> green_mantle (1)
create implication green_shawl (54) -> green_mantle (1)
create implication teal_capelet (1) -> teal_mantle (0)
create implication teal_shawl (0) -> teal_mantle (0)
create implication blue_capelet (13) -> blue_mantle (0)
create implication blue_shawl (2) -> blue_mantle (0)
create implication purple_capelet (5) -> purple_mantle (0)
create implication purple_shawl (8) -> purple_mantle (0)
create implication pink_capelet (5) -> pink_mantle (0)
create implication pink_shawl (2) -> pink_mantle (0)

Reason: From my brief research (Google/Wikipedia) it seems that all capelets and shawls are mantels, but not all mantels are ether. Do ponchos count too?

1Eyed-Rosd

Member

The bulk update request #9954 is pending approval.

create implication black_capelet (26) -> black_mantle (0)
create implication black_shawl (2) -> black_mantle (0)
create implication grey_capelet (3) -> grey_mantle (0)
create implication grey_shawl (1) -> grey_mantle (0)
create implication white_capelet (69) -> white_mantle (0)
create implication white_shawl (0) -> white_mantle (0)
create implication multicolored_capelet (3) -> multicolored_mantle (0)
create implication multicolored_shawl (2) -> multicolored_mantle (0)
create implication two_tone_capelet (3) -> two_tone_mantle (0)
create implication two_tone_shawl (0) -> two_tone_mantle (0)
create implication rainbow_capelet (0) -> rainbow_mantle (0)
create implication rainbow_shawl (0) -> rainbow_mantle (0)
create implication pride_color_capelet (0) -> pride_color_mantle (0)
create implication pride_color_shawl (2) -> pride_color_mantle (0)
create implication monotone_capelet (3) -> monotone_mantle (0)
create implication monotone_shawl (2) -> monoton_mantle (0)
create implication translucent_capelet (0) -> translucent_mantle (0)
create implication translucent_shawl (0) -> translucent_mantle (0)

Reason: The remaining colors. (For as far as I can remember.)

Watsit

Privileged

I'd rather use cloak instead of mantle, which basically means the same thing and is a more recognizable term.

1Eyed-Rosd

Member

watsit said:
I'd rather use cloak instead of mantle, which basically means the same thing and is a more recognizable term.

Someone already tried to implacat capelet with cap (forum #342849, I tried to do an imbedded link but nothing I'm trying works. I don't know what I'm doing wrong.) but it was rejected because people looking up cap probably don't want to see capelets. I am concerned that the same may apply to cloaks.

Most post under mantle just have capelets, so we already know that people looking up mantle would be satisfied with capelets. But would someone looking up cloaks be fine with capelets?

  • 1