Topic: [REJECTED] consentual_transformation misalias

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #8761 has been rejected.

remove alias consentual_transformation (0) -> transformation (76101)

Reason: Consensual transformation is not the same thing as plain transformation but does imply it.

I seemingly cannot request aliasing from consentual_transformation to consensual_transformation but I believe it should be done as well.

EDIT: The bulk update request #8761 (forum #410188) has been rejected by @spe.

Updated by auto moderator

Watsit

Privileged

veclarna said:
Reason: Consensual transformation is not the same thing as plain transformation but does imply it.

Consent is assumed for actions, unless there's visible indication it's not. consensual_sex is similarly aliased away. If it's not consensual, forced_transformation can be used. If there's reason to doubt consent but is not apparently noncon, questionable_consent can be tagged with transformation. Otherwise, if it's not non-consensual and there's no reason to doubt consent, it's just tagged transformation. There is also explicitly_stated_consent if consent is explicitly stated.

Then why is the tag consensual_transformation not aliased to transformation?

Watsit

Privileged

veclarna said:
Then why is the tag consensual_transformation not aliased to transformation?

Because no one made an alias yet. There was an alias request in topic #38485, but that was self-rejected to make it part of a BUR. That BUR in topic #38486 changed it to an implication request, which I voiced my opposition to and is still pending.

  • 1