Topic: Bag BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

user 1650047

Member

The bulk update request #8549 is pending approval.

create implication bag (12444) -> container (110221)
create implication backpack (12721) -> bag (12444)
create implication barrel_bag (15) -> bag (12444)
create implication duffel_bag (452) -> bag (12444)
create implication fanny_pack (447) -> bag (12444)
create implication golf_bag (18) -> bag (12444)
create implication handbag (1152) -> bag (12444)
create implication clutch_(bag) (66) -> handbag (1152)
create implication wristlet_(bag) (4) -> handbag (1152)
create implication frame_bag (42) -> handbag (1152)
create implication half_moon_bag (10) -> handbag (1152)
create implication ita_bag (9) -> bag (12444)
create implication messenger_bag (463) -> shoulder_bag (844)
create implication pouch_(clothing) (987) -> bag (12444)
create implication sack (1438) -> bag (12444)
create implication saddle_bag (434) -> bag (12444)
create implication shoulder_bag (844) -> bag (12444)
create implication sling_bag (99) -> bag (12444)
create implication tote_bag (67) -> bag (12444)
create implication paper_bag (744) -> bag (12444)
create implication trash_bag (750) -> bag (12444)
create implication shopping_bag (638) -> bag (12444)
create implication plastic_bag (369) -> bag (12444)
create implication gift_bag (43) -> bag (12444)
create alias gym_bag (327) -> duffel_bag (452)

Reason: These are all types of bags, so they should imply bag. Clutches, frame bags and half moon bags are specific styles of handbag.

user 1650047

Member

strikerman said:
There might be some redundancy here, namely shoulder bag vs. satchel and barrel bag vs. duffel bag. Also, plastic_bag, paper_bag, trash_bag, and others listed here

Duffel bags aren't strictly cylindrical the way barrel bags are, and not all barrel bags are duffel bags. There's definitely overlap, but they're not the same.

Removing satchel for now (I wasn't sure either tbh), and adding more bag tags, I was just focused on the worn type of bag at the moment.

That also brings up gym_bag which is another name for a duffel bag, so adding that alias to the BUR as well.

A lot of those I skipped over due to uncertainty - is classifying a bean_bag or a punching_bag as a bag useful for users, for example? I'm not sure.

Strikerman

Janitor

nimphia said:
A lot of those I skipped over due to uncertainty - is classifying a bean_bag or a punching_bag as a bag useful for users, for example? I'm not sure.

I was tempted to be a bit snarky and mention those, but I agree that the bag tag should only be used for containers.

Original page: https://e621.net/forum_topics/44994?page=1