The tag alias #69306 oriental -> invalid_tag has been rejected.

Reason: This is generally considered an offensive term. Better to use more accurate tags like chinese_clothing, etc.

EDIT: The tag alias oriental -> invalid_tag (forum #400311) has been rejected by @Cinder.

Would it be better if we moved the tag to the invalid category instead? So people can replace it with more appropriate tags.

strikerman said:
Would it be better if we moved the tag to the invalid category instead? So people can replace it with more appropriate tags.

That could be an option - I thought offensive words always went to invalid_tag though?

I believe that tag is for overall theme, mainly background, as clothing and species like pandas and dragons already have their own tags.
Maybe name it asian_theme... Just a suggestion.

Could also put it to a disambiguation. It's a breed of cat (post #3950055), it also gets used for images that are just of anthro panda or anthro eastern dragon characters with zero theming otherwise (post #2163459, post #413829).

Well first, It's only sometimes offensive, and only when referring to a person or persons. It's never offensive when describing the origin/theme of an object or scene. (EX: Oriental Rugs, Oriental noodles, etc.)

Either it should be moved to the invalid category for disambiguation, or changed to a copyright tag like christmas. I'd lean towards moving to invalid category as I don't see a theme tag like that being very useful, it would just be overtagged.

EDIT:

Also before someone suggests this, simply aliasing to east_asian wouldn't work, because oriental can refer to any part of asia, including western asia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oriental_rug

so to me moving to invalid category and making it a disambig would make the most sense.

The bulk update request #7522 is active.

change category oriental (187) -> invalid

Reason: Yeah maybe this is better

EDIT: The bulk update request #7522 (forum #400332) has been approved by @Cinder.

The bulk update request #7523 is active.

create implication oriental_rug (15) -> pattern_rug (44)
create implication pattern_rug (44) -> rug (3031)

Reason: Per the discussion in the linked topic, oriental appears too broad to be useful for tagging purposes. This should be disambiguated. (Another BUR in this topic does this)

Also added implications and wiki pages for oriental rugs because they're cool.

EDIT: The bulk update request #7523 (forum #400334) has been approved by @Cinder.

Does the decision we make for oriental set a precedent for western? I've been thinking that western should be replaced with wild_west.

aaronfranke said:
Does the decision we make for oriental set a precedent for western? I've been thinking that western should be replaced with wild_west.

I agree with wild_west, it's a clearer name

aaronfranke said:
Does the decision we make for oriental set a precedent for western? I've been thinking that western should be replaced with wild_west.

It'd cut down on the western dragon confusion.

speaking of offensive terms, we should reconsider other derogatory slangs like eskimo tag that exists.

snake-girl said:
speaking of offensive terms, we should reconsider other derogatory slangs like eskimo tag that exists.

Eskimo -> Inuit ?

i think so, but 'eskimo' is exonym for both inuits and yupiks. and i'm not sure about anyone of inuit descent on this site feel about stereotype of wearing fur parkas in artartica 24/7 constitute to the whole culture of theirs.

The tag alias oriental -> invalid_tag (forum #400311) has been rejected by @Cinder.

The bulk update request #7523 (forum #400334) has been approved by @Cinder.

The bulk update request #7522 (forum #400332) has been approved by @Cinder.