Topic: [APPROVED] Juice BUR

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #4568 is active.

remove implication apple_juice (62) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication carrot_juice (14) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication orange_juice (304) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication grape_juice (28) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication lemon_juice (0) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication raspberry_juice (0) -> beverage (65448)
remove implication tomato_juice (16) -> beverage (65448)

Reason: Part 1

Juice_(disambiguation) currently suggests fruit_juice for juice drinks. However as someone pointed out in topic #18290, there's also vegetable juice, so juice_(beverage) may work better to catch all juice beverages. (I think it sounds nicer than juice_(drink))
raspberry_juice and lemon_juice are currently empty but they were already implicated to beverage so I included them here anyway... should those be removed?
Another possibility is to have all the individual juices imply either fruit_juice or vegetable_juice and then imply fruit_juice and vegetable_juice to juice_(beverage), but I wasn't sure if that was overkill. It also might cause headaches over what counts as a fruit or a vegetable, culinary vs botanical definitions. What do you guys think?

If this is approved I'll edit the disambiguation page to add juice_(beverage).

EDIT: The bulk update request #4568 (forum #363185) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.

Updated by auto moderator

The bulk update request #4569 is active.

create implication apple_juice (62) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication carrot_juice (14) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication orange_juice (304) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication grape_juice (28) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication lemon_juice (0) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication tomato_juice (16) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication watermelon_juice (10) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication prune_juice (1) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication berry_juice (145) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create implication raspberry_juice (0) -> berry_juice (145)
create implication blueberry_juice (105) -> berry_juice (145)
create implication cranberry_juice (2) -> berry_juice (145)
create alias fruit_juice (20) -> juice_(beverage) (706)
create alias glass_of_juice (4) -> juice_(beverage) (706)

Reason: Part 2

Really not sure about aliasing away vegetable_juice when green juice blends made out of multiple vegetables are a pretty common thing. I feel like it could be useful, but at the same time it would raise issues about fruit vs vegetable like I mentioned earlier
Berry also has differences between culinary and botanical definition, but that seems more clear-cut to me? Idk

While looking through the *_juice tags I also found vacation_juice (supposed to be a cocktail lol) from Animal Crossing and gummiberry_juice from the Disney Gummi Bears series. Did not include them in this BUR but... they do exist. There's also cactus_juice which can both be an A:TLA reference and just refer to the liquid inside a cactus.

EDIT: The bulk update request #4569 (forum #363191) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.

Updated by auto moderator

Also before anyone says this is silly and irrelevant, remember the blueberry_inflation fetish? I think juice is indeed relevant to this porn site lol, there's lots of art here involving fruit juice leaking out of orifices.

  • 1