Topic: [REJECTED] Tag alias: bruised_eye -> black_eye_(injury)

The tag alias #59079 bruised_eye -> black_eye_(injury) has been rejected.

Reason: Looks to refer to the same type of injury.

EDIT: The tag alias bruised_eye -> black_eye_(injury) (forum #347276) has been rejected by @furrypickle.

From a practical standpoint, I wonder if flipping this would be clearer? A "black eye" is more of a colloquialism for it, and the term itself is not as obvious what it means.

While "bruised_eye" is more of a straightforward description for exactly what it is.

It would also be consistent with all of the other bruised_* tags. Which look undertagged but like they have a decent approach overall.

Any thoughts?

furrypickle said:
From a practical standpoint, I wonder if flipping this would be clearer? A "black eye" is more of a colloquialism for it, and the term itself is not as obvious what it means.

While "bruised_eye" is more of a straightforward description for exactly what it is.

It would also be consistent with all of the other bruised_* tags. Which look undertagged but like they have a decent approach overall.

Any thoughts?

+1 for aliasing black_eye_(injury) -> bruised_eye

I agree with flipping it. That would prevent confusion with eyes that are black or don't have an iris shown.

The bulk update request #7028 has been rejected.

create alias black_eye_(injury) (1) -> bruised_eye (1653)
remove implication black_eye_(injury) (1) -> bruised (6624)
create implication bruised_eye (1653) -> bruised (6624)

Reason: Reverse of proposed alias

EDIT: The bulk update request #7028 (forum #395066) has been rejected by @SNPtheCat.

See topic #40659

The bulk update request #7028 (forum #395066) has been rejected by @SNPtheCat.

The tag alias bruised_eye -> black_eye_(injury) (forum #347276) has been rejected by @furrypickle.