Topic: Tag Alias: first_time -> invalid_tag

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

I thought this was a bad alias at first glance, but the images tagged with first_time doesn't really make me think otherwise. Alias it away.

Updated by anonymous

Yeah +1 too this tag seem to be quite unuseful.

Updated by anonymous

tony311 said:
Invalidate, or alias to virgin?

Aliasing to virgins seams to be a better idea, it'll be easier to find virgin characters.

Updated by anonymous

tony311 said:
Invalidate, or alias to virgin?

I'd say alias it to invalid_tag, looking through first_time, I see nothing to indicate it would be better to alias it to virgin.

Edit: How the flying fuck does posts like these warrant the first_time tag in the first place, even less so when you realize how shite of a tag first_time is.
post #544441 post #251849 post #490224 post #523321 post #503602

Updated by anonymous

tony311 said:
Invalidate, or alias to virgin?

Alias to virgin. If I'd have thought of that in the first place I'd definitely have suggested that instead.

Updated by anonymous

I completely understand why people are saying to alias away first_time to --> virgin because "first time" is a fairly common phrase for someone's very first time having sex ever. So it would literally require someone to be a virgin for it to apply.

However, almost half of the images under first_time tag are not using it that way. In fact, I counted about 40 images tagged with first_time that for various reasons wouldn't belong under the virgin tag. That's too many to safely alias it away to there. Some images with first_time were actually using it for when it's the first-time-with-that-partner, which wouldn't belong under virgin tag. Some just look like normal sex pictures and there's no reason to think it's their "first time" or even their 100th time having sex - so there's a lot of mistagged images under there from that. Some just had a shocked or shy looking partner, in which case those tags should be used. It doesn't automatically mean virgin just based on that alone. And then some were better tagged with naive since we might joke that the character "must be a virgin, lol" based on their reaction or innocence to something but naive is a far more accurate way to tag those. Especially since, again, it doesn't always mean they're a virgin just because they seem clueless.

So, for those reasons, I approved aliasing first_time away to --> invalid_tag instead. With a tag that messy and mixed use, it's simply the safest option to avoid messing up any other tags with it.

Updated by anonymous

  • 1