Topic: Police BUR

The bulk update request #2026 is pending approval.

create implication police_uniform (10878) -> police (16108)
create implication police_hat (2213) -> police (16108)
create implication police_officer (3466) -> police (16108)
create implication police_badge (1185) -> police (16108)
create implication police_car (777) -> police (16108)
create implication police_brutality (137) -> police (16108)
create implication police_dog (110) -> police (16108)
create alias police_cap (91) -> police_hat (2213)

Reason: made a BUR as suggested here: https://e926.net/forum_topics/32077

the description and (per description) usage of the police seems obsolete given the existence of the police_officer tag - it is proposed that police be turned into a general umbrella tag for all police-related tags with this BUR

EDIT: whoops i accidentally tripled police_badge - meant to implicate police_brutality

achtungmaybe said:
The bulk update request #2026 is pending approval.

create implication police_uniform (10878) -> police (16108)
create implication police_hat (2213) -> police (16108)
create implication police_officer (3466) -> police (16108)
create implication police_badge (1185) -> police (16108)
create implication police_car (777) -> police (16108)
create implication police_brutality (137) -> police (16108)
create implication police_dog (110) -> police (16108)
create alias police_cap (91) -> police_hat (2213)

Reason: made a BUR as suggested here: https://e926.net/forum_topics/32077

the description and (per description) usage of the police seems obsolete given the existence of the police_officer tag - it is proposed that police be turned into a general umbrella tag for all police-related tags with this BUR

Most of those tags can exist without the existence of an actual police person.

lonelylupine said:
Most of those tags can exist without the existence of an actual police person.

Hard to say. He's not calling police a police person, he's calling it as an umbrella tag. I feel like it could be better worded to avoid people only putting it on instead of police_officer though.

furrin_gok said:
Hard to say. He's not calling police a police person, he's calling it as an umbrella tag. I feel like it could be better worded to avoid people only putting it on instead of police_officer though.

lonelylupine said:
Most of those tags can exist without the existence of an actual police person.

in any case it seems police needs a description rewrite or an alias to police_officer - though it seems reception is mixed/negative on the latter option judging from the previous forum post

Yeah, people may not want to see any police-related stuff, and an umbrella tag for police would be an easy way to blacklist it.

cloudpie said:
Yeah, people may not want to see any police-related stuff, and an umbrella tag for police would be an easy way to blacklist it.

Makes sense, but I got an earful when I used this reasoning for my BUR proposal expanding the use of the rape tag, so who knows if that will work.

lonelylupine said:
Makes sense, but I got an earful when I used this reasoning for my BUR proposal expanding the use of the rape tag, so who knows if that will work.

That’s because, if I recall correctly, you were suggesting to imply things that are not rape to the rape tag. I understand the motivation, but it still has to make logical sense or it’ll be rejected.

cloudpie said:
Yeah, people may not want to see any police-related stuff, and an umbrella tag for police would be an easy way to blacklist it.

In that case, I think a clearer tag is needed for police-related paraphernalia. To me, "police" is synonymous with "police officer(s)", and if a picture has one or more police officers, I'd be more likely to just tag it "police".

watsit said:
In that case, I think a clearer tag is needed for police-related paraphernalia. To me, "police" is synonymous with "police officer(s)", and if a picture has one or more police officers, I'd be more likely to just tag it "police".

any suggestions?

I feel like this is the most straightforward option given that people don't seem to want to alias police_officer to police

achtungmaybe said:
any suggestions?

I feel like this is the most straightforward option given that people don't seem to want to alias police_officer to police

police_paraphernalia seems good enough. Could start up a trend of _paraphernalia umbrella tags for other concepts as well.