Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions
The bulk update request #1520 is pending approval.
create alias breath_fog (74) -> breath (74101)
create alias breath_cloud (9) -> breath (74101)
create alias hot_breath (260) -> breath (74101)
create alias warm_breath (8) -> breath (74101)
create alias steam_breath (39) -> breath (74101)
Reason: All these tags are being used synonymously with the breath tag.
panting and huff got implicated to breath a couple of years ago by you know who, so breath is no longer for 'visible breath' regardless of what the wiki says.
So keeping the breath_cloud for that usage might be needed.
genjar said:
panting and huff got implicated to breath a couple of years ago by you know who...
Ah yes, another implication without a corresponding forum thread or discussion.
Why were these two implicated to breath anyways? Isn't it possible for huffing and panting be seen through sound_effects or dialogue?
And if the argument is that for one to huff or pant, they need to be seen visibly though drawn breath clouds, was animated not considered?
Not only that, but Panting is commonly tagged when a character has their mouth open with the tongue lolling out. Not much to do with the breath tag.
But 27k is a bit much to sort through.
Maybe it could be salvaged by undoing the implications and just tag scripting everything under ~panting ~huff breath with -breath.
Would remove a lot of valid ones, but better than starting a tag like breath_cloud from scratch for visible breath.
genjar said:
Not only that, but Panting is commonly tagged when a character has their mouth open with the tongue lolling out. Not much to do with the breath tag.
Might overlap with open_mouth + tongue_out (or ahegao) unless we implement a more stringent criteria for the tag; i.e., through visual breaths, sound_effects, or audible pants.
But I agree with the main idea of undoing the implications first and then salvaging the tag.
breath_cloud should be implied to breath, not aliased. Breath_cloud is used for the cartoony "cloud" to show a character exhaling, not just any visualization of breathing.
Updated
genjar said:
panting and huff got implicated to breath a couple of years ago by you know who, so breath is no longer for 'visible breath' regardless of what the wiki says.So keeping the breath_cloud for that usage might be needed.
This, essentially, too bad votes on a BUR can't be changed or removed :\
hungrymaple said:
This, essentially, too bad votes on a BUR can't be changed or removed :\
Click on the thumb or face corresponding to your vote, and that will remove the vote.
watsit said:
Click on the thumb or face corresponding to your vote, and that will remove the vote.
Thank you
hungrymaple said:
Thank you
Refresh the page after removing it and you can put a different one in.
genjar said:
panting and huff got implicated to breath a couple of years ago by you know who, so breath is no longer for 'visible breath' regardless of what the wiki says.So keeping the breath_cloud for that usage might be needed.
seconding this - the tags should be aliased to breath_cloud instead of breath
genjar said:
panting and huff got implicated to breath a couple of years ago by you know who, so breath is no longer for 'visible breath' regardless of what the wiki says.So keeping the breath_cloud for that usage might be needed.
huff seems include some images that don't involve huffing at all, but have a breath cloud... but it also includes images where there's no breath cloud, and a character is making "huff" sounds. Maybe needs some clean up...
