Topic: [REJECTED] Ear Ring and Piercing BUR (Updated)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

user 187249

Member

The bulk update request #1029 has been rejected.

create alias ear-piercings (0) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create alias barbell_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_barbell (141)
create alias barbell_ear_piercings (0) -> ear_barbell (141)
create alias ear_barbells (0) -> ear_barbell (141)
create alias barbell_earring (0) -> barbell_ear_ring (8)
create alias barbell_earrings (0) -> barbell_ear_ring (8)
create alias barbell_ear_rings (0) -> barbell_ear_ring (8)
create alias barbell_piercings (0) -> barbell_piercing (14477)
create alias barbell_(piercing) (0) -> barbell_piercing (14477)
create alias barbell_(piercings) (0) -> barbell_piercing (14477)
create alias bell_ear_piercings (0) -> bell_ear_piercing (0)
create alias bell_earring (0) -> bell_ear_ring (98)
create alias bell_earrings (0) -> bell_ear_ring (98)
create alias bell_ear_rings (0) -> bell_ear_ring (98)
create alias bell_piercings (0) -> bell_piercing (233)
create alias feather_ear_piercings (0) -> feather_ear_piercing (0)
create alias feather_earring (0) -> feather_ear_ring (488)
create alias feather_earrings (0) -> feather_ear_ring (488)
create alias feather_ear_rings (0) -> feather_ear_ring (488)
create alias feather_piercings (0) -> feather_piercing (1)
create alias <3_ear_piercing (0) -> heart_ear_piercing (57)
create alias <3_ear_piercings (0) -> heart_ear_piercing (57)
create alias heart_ear_piercings (0) -> heart_ear_piercing (57)
create alias <3_earring (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias <3_earrings (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias <3_ear_ring (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias <3_ear_rings (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias heart_earring (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias heart_earrings (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias heart_ear_rings (0) -> heart_ear_ring (93)
create alias <3_piercing (0) -> heart_piercing (123)
create alias <3_piercings (0) -> heart_piercing (123)
create alias heart_piercings (0) -> heart_piercing (123)
create alias hip_piercings (0) -> hip_piercing (662)
create alias hoop_earring (0) -> hoop_ear_ring (3435)
create alias hoop_earrings (0) -> hoop_ear_ring (3435)
create alias hoop_ear_rings (0) -> hoop_ear_ring (3435)
create alias every_piercings (0) -> multiple_piercings (5037)
create alias piercing_everywhere (0) -> multiple_piercings (5037)
create alias piercings_everywhere (4) -> multiple_piercings (5037)
create alias potara_earring (0) -> potara_ear_ring (46)
create alias potara_earrings (0) -> potara_ear_ring (46)
create alias potara_ear_rings (0) -> potara_ear_ring (46)
create alias potara (0) -> potara_ear_ring (46)
create alias single_earring (1) -> single_ear_ring (33)
create alias skull_ear_piercings (0) -> skull_ear_piercing (10)
create alias skull_earring (0) -> skull_ear_ring (114)
create alias skull_earrings (0) -> skull_ear_ring (114)
create alias skull_ear_rings (0) -> skull_ear_ring (114)
create alias skull_piercings (0) -> skull_piercing (16)
create alias star_ear_piercings (0) -> star_ear_piercing (58)
create alias star_earring (0) -> star_ear_ring (51)
create alias star_earrings (0) -> star_ear_ring (51)
create alias star_ear_rings (0) -> star_ear_ring (51)
create alias star_piercings (0) -> star_piercing (29)
create alias stud_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_stud (2852)
create alias stud_ear_piercings (0) -> ear_stud (2852)
create alias studded_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_stud (2852)
create alias studded_ear_piercings (0) -> ear_stud (2852)
create alias stud_earring (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias stud_earrings (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias stud_ear_rings (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias studded_earring (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias studded_earrings (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias studded_ear_ring (3) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias studded_ear_rings (0) -> stud_ear_ring (33)
create alias stud_piercings (0) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create alias stud_(piercing) (18) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create alias stud_(piercings) (0) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create alias studs_(piercing) (0) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create alias studs_(piercings) (0) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create alias tongue_piercings (0) -> tongue_piercing (12160)
create implication gold_piercing (1478) -> gold_(metal) (36165)
create implication gold_piercing (1478) -> piercing (494056)
create implication silver_piercing (154) -> silver_(metal) (941)
create implication silver_piercing (154) -> piercing (494056)
create implication ear_barbell (141) -> barbell_piercing (14477)
create implication ear_barbell (141) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication barbell_ear_ring (8) -> ear_barbell (141)
create implication barbell_ear_ring (8) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication barbell_piercing (14477) -> industrial_piercing (11214)
create implication bell_ear_piercing (0) -> bell_piercing (233)
create implication bell_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication bell_ear_ring (98) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication bell_ear_ring (98) -> bell_ear_piercing (0)
create implication feather_ear_piercing (0) -> feather_piercing (1)
create implication feather_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication feather_ear_ring (488) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication feather_ear_ring (488) -> feather_ear_piercing (0)
create implication feather_piercing (1) -> piercing (494056)
create implication heart_ear_piercing (57) -> heart_piercing (123)
create implication heart_ear_piercing (57) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication heart_ear_ring (93) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication heart_ear_ring (93) -> heart_ear_piercing (57)
create implication heart_piercing (123) -> piercing (494056)
create implication hip_piercing (662) -> piercing (494056)
create implication hoop_ear_ring (3435) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication potara_ear_ring (46) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication single_ear_piercing (0) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication single_ear_ring (33) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication single_ear_ring (33) -> single_ear_piercing (0)
create implication skull_ear_piercing (10) -> skull_piercing (16)
create implication skull_ear_piercing (10) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication skull_ear_ring (114) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication skull_ear_ring (114) -> skull_ear_piercing (10)
create implication skull_piercing (16) -> piercing (494056)
create implication star_ear_piercing (58) -> star_piercing (29)
create implication star_ear_piercing (58) -> ear_piercing (310302)
create implication star_ear_ring (51) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication star_ear_ring (51) -> star_ear_piercing (58)
create implication star_piercing (29) -> piercing (494056)
create implication ear_stud (2852) -> stud_piercing (1105)
create implication stud_ear_ring (33) -> ear_stud (2852)
create implication stud_ear_ring (33) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication stud_piercing (1105) -> piercing (494056)

Reason: An updated BUR for various aliases and implications for ear_ring, ear_piercing, and piercing (derived from topic #29769). Let me know if anything on this BUR should be edited.

Edits

EDIT: The bulk update request #1029 (forum #312070) has been rejected by @Rainbow_Dash.

Updated by auto moderator

user 187249

Member

The bulk update request #1031 has been rejected.

remove alias rainbow_earrings (0) -> rainbow_earring (0)
create alias black_earring (0) -> black_ear_ring (87)
create alias black_earrings (0) -> black_ear_ring (87)
create alias black_ear_rings (0) -> black_ear_ring (87)
create alias blue_earring (0) -> blue_ear_ring (177)
create alias blue_earrings (0) -> blue_ear_ring (177)
create alias blue_ear_rings (0) -> blue_ear_ring (177)
create alias brown_earring (0) -> brown_ear_ring (7)
create alias brown_earrings (0) -> brown_ear_ring (7)
create alias brown_ear_rings (0) -> brown_ear_ring (7)
create alias green_earring (0) -> green_ear_ring (68)
create alias green_earrings (0) -> green_ear_ring (68)
create alias green_ear_rings (0) -> green_ear_ring (68)
create alias grey_earring (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias grey_earrings (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias grey_ear_rings (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias gray_earring (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias gray_earrings (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias gray_ear_ring (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias gray_ear_rings (0) -> grey_ear_ring (49)
create alias orange_earring (0) -> orange_ear_ring (0)
create alias orange_earrings (0) -> orange_ear_ring (0)
create alias orange_ear_rings (0) -> orange_ear_ring (0)
create alias pink_earring (0) -> pink_ear_ring (25)
create alias pink_earrings (0) -> pink_ear_ring (25)
create alias pink_ear_rings (0) -> pink_ear_ring (25)
create alias purple_earring (0) -> purple_ear_ring (65)
create alias purple_earrings (5) -> purple_ear_ring (65)
create alias purple_ear_rings (0) -> purple_ear_ring (65)
create alias red_earring (0) -> red_ear_ring (75)
create alias red_earrings (0) -> red_ear_ring (75)
create alias red_ear_rings (0) -> red_ear_ring (75)
create alias tan_earring (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias tan_earrings (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias tan_ear_rings (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias beige_earring (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias beige_earrings (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias beige_ear_ring (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias beige_ear_rings (0) -> tan_ear_ring (0)
create alias white_earring (0) -> white_ear_ring (13)
create alias white_earrings (0) -> white_ear_ring (13)
create alias white_ear_rings (0) -> white_ear_ring (13)
create alias yellow_earring (0) -> yellow_ear_ring (72)
create alias yellow_earrings (0) -> yellow_ear_ring (72)
create alias yellow_ear_rings (0) -> yellow_ear_ring (72)
create alias monotone_earring (0) -> monotone_ear_ring (8)
create alias monotone_earrings (0) -> monotone_ear_ring (8)
create alias monotone_ear_rings (0) -> monotone_ear_ring (8)
create alias multicolored_earring (0) -> multicolored_ear_ring (4)
create alias multicolored_earrings (0) -> multicolored_ear_ring (4)
create alias multicolored_ear_rings (0) -> multicolored_ear_ring (4)
create alias two_tone_earring (0) -> two_tone_ear_ring (1)
create alias two_tone_earrings (0) -> two_tone_ear_ring (1)
create alias two_tone_ear_rings (0) -> two_tone_ear_ring (1)
create alias gold_earring (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias gold_earrings (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias gold_ear_rings (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias golden_earring (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias golden_ear_ring (6) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias golden_earrings (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias golden_ear_rings (0) -> gold_ear_ring (1798)
create alias silver_earring (0) -> silver_ear_ring (121)
create alias silver_earrings (0) -> silver_ear_ring (121)
create alias silver_ear_rings (0) -> silver_ear_ring (121)
create implication black_ear_ring (87) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication blue_ear_ring (177) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication brown_ear_ring (7) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication green_ear_ring (68) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication grey_ear_ring (49) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication orange_ear_ring (0) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication pink_ear_ring (25) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication purple_ear_ring (65) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication red_ear_ring (75) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication tan_ear_ring (0) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication white_ear_ring (13) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication yellow_ear_ring (72) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication monotone_ear_ring (8) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication multicolored_ear_ring (4) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication two_tone_ear_ring (1) -> multicolored_ear_ring (4)
create implication gold_ear_ring (1798) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication gold_ear_ring (1798) -> gold_piercing (1478)
create implication silver_ear_ring (121) -> ear_ring (128593)
create implication silver_ear_ring (121) -> silver_piercing (154)

Reason: Various [color]_ear_ring aliases and implications (as well as aliases and implications for gold_ear_ring and silver_ear_ring).

Tags For Another BUR

alias rainbow_earring -> rainbow_ear_ring
alias rainbow_earrings -> rainbow_ear_ring
alias rainbow_ear_rings -> rainbow_ear_ring
imply rainbow_ear_ring -> multicolored_ear_ring

EDIT: The bulk update request #1031 (forum #312072) has been rejected by @Rainbow_Dash.

Updated by auto moderator

Fluffball

Member

Yellow marking this for now. It seems mostly find. Only a few things that needs to be scrutinized a bit more thoroughly IMO.

I'm unsure about mixing piercings with jewelry in some of these implications. So far these groups have been kept separate. It is difficult to argue that a piercing is always jewelry.

- barbell_ear_piercing is inconsistent with other barbell piercing tags, nipple_barbell for example. ear_barbell would be more consistent with ear_stud. Specific piercing categories (stud, ring, barbell) tend to use the format <body part> <piercing type>. It also tends to be nice to group body part related things with the body part.

- Also I noticed that you have a tag for only one ear ring. Perhaps you should have a tag that would apply for any ear piercing.

Updated

user 187249

Member

thevileone said:

Yellow marking this for now. It seems mostly find. Only a few things that needs to be scrutinized a bit more thoroughly IMO.

I'm unsure about mixing piercings with jewelry in some of these implications. So far these groups have been kept separate. It is difficult to argue that a piercing is always jewelry.

- barbell_ear_piercing is inconsistent with other barbell piercing tags, nipple_barbell for example. ear_barbell would be more consistent with ear_stud. Specific piercing categories (stud, ring, barbell) tend to use the format <body part> <piercing type>. It also tends to be nice to group body part related things with the body part.

- Also I noticed that you have a tag for only one ear ring. Perhaps you should have a tag that would apply for any ear piercing.

I've updated the BUR based on your suggestions, though I'm also wondering if the barbell_ear_ring tags should be aliased to ear_barbell as well.

spe

Admin

Gonna bump this partially because I was about to suggest some of the same things, and this is also a pretty detailed BUR that’s been sitting for a while, so I think we should take another look at getting it approved.

I was thinking of making my own BUR for some of these before I found this. While we’re here, I think some piercings (like ear_ring and ear_stud) should imply jewelry. Not all piercings may be considered jewelry, but those (and possibly some others) definitely are. It may be a good idea to add those to this BUR as well.

Original page: https://e621.net/forum_topics/29931?page=1