Topic: [REJECTED] Nothing But Fruit Left At The Picnic (fruit Bulk Update Request)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #678 has been rejected.

remove alias apples (0) -> apple (7891)
remove implication apple (7891) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication avocado (53) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias bananas (0) -> banana (3087)
remove implication banana (3087) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias berries (0) -> berry (1392)
remove implication berry (1392) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication holding_berry (54) -> berry (1392)
remove alias blackberries (0) -> blackberry (5)
remove implication blackberry_(fruit) (29) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication blueberry_(fruit) (489) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias cherries (0) -> cherry (2170)
remove implication cherry (2170) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias grapes (0) -> grape (1318)
remove implication grapes (0) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias kiwi_(fruit) (0) -> kiwifruit (158)
remove implication kiwifruit (158) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication lime (286) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication melon (2115) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication cantaloupe (26) -> melon (2115)
remove implication holding_melon (69) -> melon (2115)
remove implication honeydew_melon (11) -> melon (2115)
remove implication watermelon (1881) -> melon (2115)
remove implication pear (417) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication persimmon (16) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication pineapple (635) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias pumpkins (0) -> pumpkin (10381)
remove implication pumpkin (10381) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias raisins (0) -> raisin (25)
remove implication raisin (25) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias raspberries (0) -> raspberry (152)
remove implication raspberry (152) -> fruit (41649)
remove alias strawberries (0) -> strawberry (2799)
remove implication strawberry (2799) -> fruit (41649)
remove implication tomato (883) -> fruit (41649)
create alias blood_orange (0) -> blood_orange_(fruit) (5)
create alias jackfruit (1) -> jackfruit_(fruit) (0)
create alias starfruit (17) -> starfruit_(fruit) (0)
create alias tangerine (22) -> tangerine_(fruit) (82)
create alias mango (73) -> mango_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias mango_(character) (2) -> mango_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias mango_(oc) (0) -> mango_(disambiguation) (0)
create alias peaches (3) -> peach_(fruit) (645)
create implication apple_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication avocado_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication banana_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication berry_(fruit) (1) -> fruit (41649)
create implication holding_berry (54) -> berry_(fruit) (1)
create implication blackberry_(fruit) (29) -> berry_(fruit) (1)
create implication blueberry_(fruit) (489) -> berry_(fruit) (1)
create implication raspberry_(fruit) (0) -> berry_(fruit) (1)
create implication strawberry_(fruit) (0) -> berry_(fruit) (1)
create implication blood_orange_(fruit) (5) -> orange_(fruit) (966)
create implication cherry_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication cherry_tomato (0) -> tomato_(fruit) (0)
create implication date_(fruit) (5) -> fruit (41649)
create implication devil_fruit (11) -> fruit (41649)
create implication fruit_of_knowledge (1) -> fruit (41649)
create implication glowing_fruit (4) -> fruit (41649)
create implication glowing_fruit (4) -> glowing (100120)
create implication grape_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication grapefruit_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication heart_fruit (3) -> fruit (41649)
create implication jackfruit_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication lemon_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication lime_(fruit) (11) -> fruit (41649)
create implication lychee_(fruit) (2) -> fruit (41649)
create implication melon_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication cantaloupe_melon (0) -> melon_(fruit) (0)
create implication holding_melon (69) -> melon_(fruit) (0)
create implication honeydew_melon (11) -> melon_(fruit) (0)
create implication watermelon (1881) -> melon_(fruit) (0)
create implication miracle_fruit (2) -> fruit (41649)
create implication papaya_(fruit) (14) -> fruit (41649)
create implication passion_fruit (6) -> fruit (41649)
create implication pear_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication persimmon_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication pineapple_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication plum_(fruit) (77) -> fruit (41649)
create implication pomegranate_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication pumpkin_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication raisin_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication silver_peanut_butter_fruit (1) -> peanut_butter_fruit (1)
create implication peanut_butter_fruit (1) -> fruit (41649)
create implication starfruit_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)
create implication tomato_(fruit) (0) -> fruit (41649)

Reason: Standardization of the fruit tags to include the *_(fruit) suffix (to help distinguish between fruits, and characters named after fruits). Derived from topic #21497.

  • Let me know if any of these fruit tags should be disambiguations instead.
Tags For Another BUR

alias apple -> apple_(fruit)
alias apples -> apple_(fruit)
alias avocado -> avocado_(fruit)
alias banana -> banana_(fruit)
alias bananas -> banana_(fruit)
alias berry -> berry_(fruit)
alias berries -> berry_(fruit)
alias blackberry -> blackberry_(fruit)
alias blackberries -> blackberry_(fruit)
alias cherry -> cherry_(fruit)
alias cherries -> cherry_(fruit)
alias grape -> grape_(fruit)
alias grapes -> grape_(fruit)
alias kiwifruit -> kiwi_(fruit)
alias lime -> lime_(fruit)
alias melon -> melon_(fruit)
alias cantaloupe -> cantaloupe_melon
alias pear -> pear_(fruit)
alias pineapple -> pineapple_(fruit)
alias pineapples -> pineapple_(fruit)
alias persimmon -> persimmon_(fruit)
alias persimmons -> persimmon_(fruit)
alias pumpkin -> pumpkin_(fruit)
alias pumpkins -> pumpkin_(fruit)
alias raisin -> raisin_(fruit)
alias raisins -> raisin_(fruit)
alias raspberry -> raspberry_(fruit)
alias raspberries -> raspberry_(fruit)
alias strawberry -> strawberry_(fruit)
alias strawberries -> strawberry_(fruit)
alias tomato -> tomato_(fruit)
imply kiwi_(fruit) -> fruit

EDIT: The bulk update request #678 (forum #304700) has been rejected by @Millcore.

Updated by auto moderator

A few missing tags:

alias açaí -> acai_(disambiguation)
alias acai -> acai_(disambiguation)
alias açaí_(fruit) -> acai_berry
alias acai_(fruit) -> acai_berry
alias açaí_berry -> acai_berry
imply acai_berry -> berry_(fruit)

Reminder to implicate acai_palm to tree in a possible future BUR (and alias the Unicode version(s) too).

alias guaraná -> guarana_(disambiguation)
alias guarana -> guarana_(disambiguation)
alias guaraná_soda -> guarana_(soda)
imply guarana_soda -> soda
alias guaraná_(fruit) -> guarana_(fruit)
imply guarana_(fruit) -> fruit

soft_drink should probably be aliased to soda, but perhaps that is out of the scope of this BUR.

  • achiote -> Achiote (it might also be a good idea to alias urucum or urucum_(fruit) to achiote or achiote_(fruit))
alias achiote -> achiote_(disambiguation)
alias urucum -> urucum_(disambiguation)
alias urucum_(fruit) -> achiote_(fruit)
imply achiote_(fruit) -> fruit
  • alias passionfruit to passion_fruit and implicate the latter to fruit (maybe alias maracuja_(fruit) too?)
alias passionfruit -> passion_fruit
imply passion_fruit -> fruit
alias maracujá -> maracuja_(disambiguation)
alias maracuja -> maracuja_(disambiguation)
alias maracujá_(fruit) -> passion_fruit
alias maracuja_(fruit) -> passion_fruit

Updated

Do we start using "canine_(species)" if somebody names their character Canine, too? The actual object/concept should take tagging priority over characters named after the item in question IMHO.

votp said:
Do we start using "canine_(species)" if somebody names their character Canine, too? The actual object/concept should take tagging priority over characters named after the item in question IMHO.

I would call that an "apples to oranges comparison", but there is indeed a similar precedent for that.

I don't really like the idea of automatically suffixing every fruit tag with (fruit), I think it should be taken on a case-by-case basis where the tag is frequently misused.

As for aliasing banana to banana_(fruit) and all the other X -> X_(fruit) seem like they'll undo the entire point of this anyway, because anybody who would tag their OC as "banana" isn't going to pay attention to the fact it changes to "banana_(fruit)" after they post it and nothing will change from before it was aliased.

Let me know which of these fruit tags would be fine without the *_(fruit) suffix, and I'll edit this BUR to correct it. I already figure that jackfruit doesn't need the suffix.

Several other fruit tags would probably be better incorporating the *_(fruit) suffix since some of these tags have been used as names for multiple characters, like with lemon and lime.

  • 1