The bulk update request #177 is active.

create implication penectomy (433) -> genital_mutilation (1535)
create implication castration (870) -> cock_and_ball_torture (5656)
create implication penectomy (433) -> cock_and_ball_torture (5656)
create implication severed_genitals (448) -> genital_mutilation (1535)
create implication severed_balls (258) -> severed_genitals (448)
create implication severed_penis (243) -> severed_genitals (448)
create implication severed_balls (258) -> cock_and_ball_torture (5656)
create implication severed_penis (243) -> cock_and_ball_torture (5656)
create implication severed_balls (258) -> balls (1032069)
create implication severed_penis (243) -> penis (1513197)
create implication genital_mutilation (1535) -> mutilation (2103)
create implication clit_torture (211) -> pussy_torture (775)

Reason: Obviously all genital mutilation, and the CBT tag's description is broad enough as to cover mutilation, and thus these tags. Maybe castration should be fit in here, but its page implies it's the process of removing the balls, so not really I guess. Maybe it should imply CBT, though? But it can be done via chemical castration which doesn't really fit the traditional definition of CBT at all. Then again, it already implies genital mutilation, so...

EDIT: Threw penectomy implying genital mutilation in there. Still believe there's an argument for both to imply CBT.

The broad definition of ballbusting also means severed balls could debatably implicate it.

I'd throw nullification in here, but the tag seems to be used a lot for sexless transformation, which is a pretty massive mistagging situation. Also, maybe mutilation should imply gore. Exposed testicle is also a tag referenced, though it's not as mistagged as I originally thought. I dunno how it should fit into this though. It doesn't necessarily have anything to do with genital torture.

EDIT: The bulk update request #177 (forum #294382) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.

A year later and I decided to roll more genital mutilation into this. Pussy torture says "The pussy and/or clitoris being injured or otherwise punished in some fashion", so clit torture should implicate it I guess.

There remains outstanding mistagging situations and strange cases, such as chemical castration (should this imply CBT? Probably should be its own tag honestly, which implies Castration). Penectomy should also count as CBT I think still. And Exposed testicle is a weird tag, no idea what to do with that. Besides make it imply gore, maybe.

Also, do we not have a severed clitoris tag?

I think the BUR I made at topic #30203 may be relevant to this one.

Currently, I think this one looks fine the way it is.

Oh it absolutely is. The more you know about genital torture! What a beautiful world.

opilione said:
Oh it absolutely is. The more you know about genital torture! What a beautiful world.

…yes, indeed. I learned a lot that day; things I had never wished to learn. Someone’s got to get these tags in order, though.

It's been nearly two years so I'm gonna bump this.

Is there anything else this is missing, too? I want to keep this comprehensive.

I was told that bumping is not very effective.

I'd just like to get more input at the least about any tags I might be missing here.

The bulk update request #177 (forum #294382) has been approved by @Rainbow_Dash.

Currently the penectomy wiki says it should also be used for characters who've had their dick removed in the past, not just the process currently happening. This doesn't match all the other tags like castration vs castrated and of course now that it implies genital_mutilation that line in the wiki is for sure incorrect.

I'd like to fix the wiki and clean up the tag, but what tag should be used for post-penectomy characters? Just nullo doesn't work because sometimes they still have balls, and nullo is for both dick and balls removed.

I'm going to use penectomized I guess

I'm just going to bump this thread because, are we sure we want to have severed_<body_part> imply <body_part> like this? I mean, it's not a huge deal, but I think we generally try to keep the stuff that isn't currently part of a "character" seperate, from what I understood which, I assumed, was why stuff like penis_tentacle and didn't imply penis.

also the implications to cock_and_ball_torture seem... odd?