Aliasing closed_mouth → invalid_tag
Link to alias

Reason:

Do we really need a tag for both closed_mouth AND open_mouth? Either your mouth is closed or its open; there isn't an in between. "closed_mouth" has significantly less pics, so let's nuke that one. "-open_mouth" will do for searching.

Keep open_mouth, nuke closed_mouth

Yep, I don't think it's needed.

Similar alias was discussed in forum #83095: eyes_open got aliased to invalid_tag, for the same reason.

(There's also the closed tag, which is mostly used for closed mouth or closed eyes. That one's even less useful..)

TheHuskyK9 said:
Keep open_mouth, nuke closed_mouth

post #242916 post #197182 post #155482

Xch3l said:
post #242916 post #197182 post #155482

:O

I agree as closed_mouth (more or less) is the natural form of the mouth or rather should I say where it is most often found

I'm sure this was already aliased at one point. I support its nuking.

Xch3l said:
post #242916 post #197182 post #155482

Is it normal that I can hear them gasping?

TheHuskyK9 said:
Is it normal that I can hear them gasping?

I can hear "AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA" so it's either normal or we're both fucked.

TheHuskyK9 said:
Is it normal that I can hear them gasping?

it might be

I disagree. Partially opened mouths exist. open mouth as we use it is indicative of a fully open mouth. closed mouth is indicative of a firmly shut mouth. if the lips are pressed together, it should be tagged as such.

123easy said:
I disagree. Partially opened mouths exist. open mouth as we use it is indicative of a fully open mouth. closed mouth is indicative of a firmly shut mouth. if the lips are pressed together, it should be tagged as such.

Might help to post an example to support your case.
----

Currently, I agree with nuking this tag.

123easy said:
I disagree. Partially opened mouths exist. open mouth as we use it is indicative of a fully open mouth. closed mouth is indicative of a firmly shut mouth. if the lips are pressed together, it should be tagged as such.

I think then perhaps we could have a more specific tag like pursed_lips or clenched_mouth

Rainbow_Dash said:
I think then perhaps we could have a more specific tag like pursed_lips or clenched_mouth

That sounds like a better idea. I like pursed lips, since we already have clenched_teeth or something of the sort where the lips are spread but the jaw is firmly closed.