Topic: Beach Horse Young Tags

Posted under Tag/Wiki Projects and Questions

Now that post #2423387 has it's young tags added and locked, shouldn't the rest of the pool follow suit? Figured best to ask first.

It's the exact same characters with the same designs posted on the same day. It doesn't make much sense for one instance of them to be tagged as young and the others in the same sequence to not be.

Updated

Ehh... Honestly the previous three images each look a lot more ambiguous than the last. I can see why the tags are as they are currently, as you don't really get a great perspective on their bodily proportions, except for the last one, imo.

Quenir has it. In the first three, it's unclear the cat and fox are young or simply smaller than the horse. Indeed, it's somewhat unclear if they're all that much smaller than the horse, thanks to perspective and framing. On the other hand, in #2423387, it's clear they're younger and smaller.

You should never "carry over" tags from either the previous or next post from the pool.
Each post is determined individually and that includes their visually apparent age as per TWYS.

If you are confident that they appear young in the other posts, you may tag it as such.
Otherwise, consider any ambiguity the posts may present and do not blindly tag all as young when they do not warrant it.

Original page: https://e621.net/forum_topics/60204