Topic: Tag Alias: torn_ear -> notched_ear

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Seven_Twenty said:
Aliasing torn_ear → notched_ear
Link to alias

Reason:

same thing

Ehhh... is it? If it's notched, it might have been specifically cut that way, or cut rather precisely. Comparatively, if something is torn, it implies ragged edges, uneven lines, a general sense of a natural tear, be it from a fight or from getting something caught on something sharp and it tearing jaggedly.

Not against the alias, just something for consideration.

Updated by anonymous

123easy said:
Ehhh... is it? If it's notched, it might have been specifically cut that way, or cut rather precisely. Comparatively, if something is torn, it implies ragged edges, uneven lines, a general sense of a natural tear, be it from a fight or from getting something caught on something sharp and it tearing jaggedly.

Not against the alias, just something for consideration.

Are you sure that there are enough people that care about these details so that they would search/blacklist, and tag them properly? Would anyone think, when tagging, whether it's cut or torn? Both tags are underused already, I don't think it's wise to leave them like that.

Updated by anonymous

Gilda_The_Gryphon said:
Are you sure that there are enough people that care about these details so that they would search/blacklist, and tag them properly? Would anyone think, when tagging, whether it's cut or torn? Both tags are underused already, I don't think it's wise to leave them like that.

This is why I stated not against the alias, just bringing it up for consideration. :)-

Updated by anonymous

  • 1