Topic: [BUR] "Full Version At Paywall"

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

The bulk update request #9961 is pending approval.

create implication full_version_at_paywall (134) -> alternate_version_at_paywall (808)
create implication full_version_at_paywall (134) -> preview (683)
change category full_version_at_paywall (134) -> meta

Reason: Implications and category change for full_version_at_paywall.

Though, not sure of the first one, whether 'full version' should be considered 'alternate' or not. Will remove if there's enough against it or a mod says so.

Watsit

Privileged

I'd say an alias would be better. The distinction between an alternate and a full version isn't always clear, if what's released can be considered complete on its own (e.g. the difference between a public version being incomplete and the pay version being complete, vs a public version being a short standalone thing and the pay version being a longer extended cut). "Full version" is also somewhat vague; does it count for hi-res pay version, where the image is the same but the public version is smaller and the pay version is full size? What about a comic where there's some extra pages behind a paywall, maybe some extra background fluff or extra/extended sex scenes, but aren't needed to follow along? The general issue with paywall content is also that not everyone is capable of verifying correct tags, so the fewer tags that rely on specific differences from a non-public version, the better (especially true if there's a timed public release, making these tags become obsolete and needing removal after a time; more specific tags would result in needing more cleanup everytime it happens).

Updated

  • 1