I'm a fairly casual user so hopefully this is the right way to go about this.
I am somewhat aware of the recent changes and controversy around the tag but this is not regarding that.
I'd like to get others to weigh in on some recent use of the young tag rather than just changing things.

Looking at 4613475 and the rest of the images in the set.
IMO they shouldn't be tagged young.
The wiki for the tag says "Less sexually dimorphic figures than adults, lacking broad shoulders, wide hips, or developed breasts." so large developed breasts would tip the scale in the direction of not young, right?

A maybe more grey area I also noticed is 4613104.
I also think this should not be tagged young.

My main concern is developing a trend of anime=young.
Anime style tends to have larger heads and especially larger eyes but IMO without other indicators or particularly with contrary indicators the large head/eyes in anime art should either not be considered or should be considered less when determining age tags.

dracotheblack said:
Looking at 4613475 and the rest of the images in the set.
IMO they shouldn't be tagged young.
The wiki for the tag says "Less sexually dimorphic figures than adults, lacking broad shoulders, wide hips, or developed breasts." so large developed breasts would tip the scale in the direction of not young, right?

post #4613475

I would tend to agree that this character looks more like an adult than young here. I tend to avoid basing any age judgments off of bust size too much because it tends to vary wildly in both adult characters and oppai_lolis, but with everything else in the image I'd lean towards removing young.