Topic: Tag Alias: dock -> dock_(disambiguation)

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

+1. The term is also applied to partially removed tails or ears, typically seen in some dog breeds.

Siral_Exan said:
+1, dock_(anatomy) or dock_(tail) for the current use are my suggestions.

Due the possible usage cited above, both suggestions possibly wouldn't work.

Updated by anonymous

O16 said:
+1. The term is also applied to partially removed tails or ears, typically seen in some dog breeds.

Due the possible usage cited above, both suggestions possibly wouldn't work.

Got a better idea? In all seriousness, let's brainstorm.

Updated by anonymous

Siral_Exan said:
Got a better idea? In all seriousness, let's brainstorm.

'equine_dock' maybe?

edit: forget that, bad idea.

Updated by anonymous

Genjar

Former Staff

Yeah, definitely needs a disambiguation.
The wiki usage of dock seems specific to the MLP fandom. Everyone else uses it for piers, shipyards, etc.

dock -equine -mlp only finds dozen posts (out of 4757), and that's mostly because the boat docks have been sorted out.

Updated by anonymous

Snowy said:
dock_(anatomy) for the anatomical structure, docked_tail and docked_ear for partially removed tails and ears. dock_(tail) would be an easier tag but seems more likely to induce mistags due to similarity with docked_tail. Wikipedia also suggests tailhead for the anatomical structure, but that's too close to tail_head for my liking.

hum…

I) Maybe docked tails don't need a specific tag, they probably would fall under 'short_tail' or 'amputation'.

II) I am still not sure about 'dock_anatomy', it sounds like the sort of thing that would be mistagged, since docking is a body modification (isn't uncommon for people to connect "anatomy" to "body aspects", even when these aspects have been modified).

Updated by anonymous

Genjar said:
Yeah, definitely needs a disambiguation.
The wiki usage of dock seems specific to the MLP fandom. Everyone else uses it for piers, shipyards, etc.

I think that's more because the dock is most visible on equines, not necessarily because it's MLP specific.

Updated by anonymous

Bringing this back up. Dock should be either disambiguated or aliased to dock_(anatomy), so people will know that their interpretation of dock isn't the same.

Updated by anonymous

TheVileOne said:
Bringing this back up. Dock should be either disambiguated or aliased to dock_(anatomy), so people will know that their interpretation of dock isn't the same.

+1, dock (in it's current use) should be migrated to dock_(anatomy) or dock_(tail), and then dock should be aliased to dock_(disambiguation).

I've been a regular tagger of dock (as the wiki currently describes it) and I feel the tag should be disambiguated, since it could be used for multiple other tags such as pier, docking, dock_piercing, or docked_tail.

Updated by anonymous

scaliespe said:
Hold up. Why

Yes, this is definitely in need of disambiguation. A waterside dock, an animal's docked ears/tail, docking (penis penetrating sheath), and the anatomical structure some animals have for the piece of tail just above the anus. If nothing else, it is regularly confused for a pier, and there are still posts using it for a pier.

scaliespe said:
Hold up. Why

There's been several disambiguation tags that have been rejected tonight, all having been pending for quite a long time and all I would have called valid. Has it been so long that better solutions are now available or were they gumming up the works as they were before?

  • 1