Topic: Tag suggestion: Talonjob

Posted under Tag Alias and Implication Suggestions

Not sure if enough posts like that exist to warrant a tag for it, but there are footjob, beakjob, and tailjob tags which are populated and in use

So what about other *job tags for various anatomies?

few examples I could find:

(All currently tagged with footjob)

post #426218

post #424498

post #308355

If talonjob sounds silly, suggestions are welcome
-
Possible implications suggested by Jugofthat :

implicate beakjob -> fellatio
implicate talonjob -> footjob

Updated

My opinion? Nah.

While I'm all for talons getting tagged since they look so recognizable and have a special appeal to some people, a talon is still a foot, so masturbation with it is a footjob.

In the same way I'm also okay with 'beak' being a tag, since that's very functional, but a beakjob... why exactly? It's just oral, anything more specific (while nice) seems superfluous. Searching for beak + oral should do the same job in most cases. Or well, aside from not specifying whether the one with the beak is on the receiving end or not. I get that.

Point is, if you start making these kinds of exceptions for bird-specific anatomy it opens the door for hoovejobs and shark maw jobs, or perhaps some umbrella tag like 'how_the_hell_can_any_dick_survive_this_job' for sharp teeth in general. All that really does is extend the list of stuff that you (as a good tagger) feel obligated to watch out for and include.

Like, it's not entirely pointless but that also means you can't just go around leaving it out like some tags, but at the same time it still feels a bit like it's bordering on clutter.

Anyway, if we're going to go through with this we should at least make sure to implicate footjob to talonjob, so that we don't create a situation in which people start tagging only the latter. Beakjob also should have oral as an implication if it doesn't already.

Updated by anonymous

Lance_Armstrong said:
Just do it™

Hah, I waited because I was expecting a response like Jugofthat's

Jugofthat said:
My opinion? Nah.[...]
Point is, if you start making these kinds of exceptions for bird-specific anatomy it opens the door for hoovejobs and shark maw jobs, or perhaps some umbrella tag like 'how_the_hell_can_any_dick_survive_this_job' for sharp teeth in general. All that really does is extend the list of stuff that you (as a good tagger) feel obligated to watch out for and include.

Like, it's not entirely pointless but that also means you can't just go around leaving it out like some tags, but at the same time it still feels a bit like it's bordering on clutter.

That's a good point; it wouldn't make much sense for tags to be introduced and no one was using them

But, I think that if people knew they were in use, there'd be a number of people (talon fetish, beak fetish etc?) who would make sure to tag it in (see below)

Kämpfer said:
I don't think it's a bad idea, but I doubt many people would remember to tag this.

That's fine for now (if it does become an official tag)
With enough time that might change

Jugofthat said:
Anyway, if we're going to go through with this we should at least make sure to implicate footjob to talonjob, so that we don't create a situation in which people start tagging only the latter. Beakjob also should have oral as an implication if it doesn't already.

Definitely. Added to the OP (changed the beakjob -> oral implication to beakjob -> fellatio, because fellatio implies oral)

Updated by anonymous

  • 1