Implicating male_penetrating → sex
Link to implication

Reason:

male_penetrating -> sex
female_penetrating -> sex
intersex_penetrating -> sex
As far as I'm aware, these haven't been discussed yet.

Related: forum #186975 forum #210963

EDIT: The tag implication male_penetrating -> sex (forum #239069) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.

-1. penetration =/= sex

BlueDingo said:
-1. penetration =/= sex

True, but '[gender]_penetrating' tags are used to specify gender of the individual who is penetrating during sex. There is absolutely no reason for specifying gender of the character who is penetrating, if it is penetrating itself (masturbation).

+1. Reason above.

O16 said:
True, but '[gender]_penetrating' is used to specify the gender of the individual who is penetrating during sex. There is absolutely no reason for specifying the gender of the character who is penetrating in cases of masturbation (because it is the gender of the character itself).

+1. Reason above.

The real issue is when there's a strap-on: It's still [gender]_penetrating, but is it sex? The other discussion made me realize that it's probably toying_partner. This is unfortunate for the male_penetrating implication because it almost never involves a strap-on, but could by technicality...

But now someone suggested toying_partner -> sex in the other thread, so...

CrocoGator said:
The real issue is when there's a strap-on: It's still [gender]_penetrating, but is it sex?

Yes, as is most other toy use on the partner (except when it counts as foreplay or immediate_sex). It's certainly not masturbation.

-1, what if they're screwing a watermelon or something? That's not really sex, its more masturbation. Exceptions invalidate the rule when it comes to implications and aliases.

Azula_Arktandr said:
-1, what if they're screwing a watermelon or something? That's not really sex, its more masturbation. Exceptions invalidate the rule when it comes to implications and aliases.

See the wiki

General: male penetrating
Used for posts depicting a male character penetrating another character, regardless of the gender of the latter.

A watermelon isn't another character.

CrocoGator said:
A watermelon isn't another character.

Except when it is.

post #1277312post #1150193

The tag implication male_penetrating -> sex (forum #239069) has been rejected by @NotMeNotYou.